
As many of you may recall, the central wedge issue in the 2022 election was whether or not the community wanted us to proceed with the previously awarded RFP for the Midland Bay Landing property. That RFP came back with dozens of high end town homes to be built on the eastern side of the lands (the side we all enjoy) as phase one and the potential but uncosted development of more commercial offerings on the remaining western lands (closer to downtown) as phase 2 about a decade or so later.
That plan did not resonate with much of the community and the majority of council was elected on the “pause and re-think” platform to see if the project could be altered to allow for more public spaces and some parkland on the eastern side that so many loved and use daily.
The proponent read and heard about the widespread rejection of the plan, was not keen to change course and was also dealing with cost estimate overruns in the tens of millions and opted to exit the deal shortly after the election and during their due diligence window.
In honouring our pledges to return to the community to refresh the consultation before making another RFP attempt, we collected fresh input, fed all that into the new RFP with KPMG’s help and put the project back on the market with loads of technical and environmental study data we purchased from the previous proponent and combined that with no zoning or official plan constraints… A blank slate with all the new community feedback. This seemed like a winning combination.
What we got back was nothing remotely aligned with all that feedback, so we unanimously rejected the submission and here we are – not for lack of trying.
We have built on the failures of the last two town attempts and had hoped for the best but the market conditions were a major obstacle.
We now have a ready-to-go RFP that could go back to market when the economy picks up, or we could pivot to another option that I outlined in the MidlandToday article https://www.midlandtoday.ca/local-news/mayor-underwhelmed-with-proposal-for-midland-bay-landing-12403300
Many communities with major waterfront developments (Orillia, Collingwood, Wasaga as nearby examples) have had to do successive rounds of RFP until they land on a winner. Accepting an underwhelming submission, just to say we “did something” is not a responsible path forward.
So, while we wait on the market conditions to improve we are clearing some of the land, cleaning the area up, making it safer, adding some trails and fixing up the parking lot with minimal investment. The east side is slowly being upgraded to be more like a rec/park space while we decide how to approach the western 2/3 of the land and see something other than high end housing in its future. We have plenty of that already rimming the bay.
As it stands now, your mayor and council were not willing to award a waterfront housing subdivision proposal on Midland Bay Landing when the community rejected that in 2022 and when we know that this last piece of waterfront in Midland can be so much more with the right mix of design elements, including a waterfront park/recreational space and continued public access to all 1100m of shoreline.
If you think we got it wrong and should have just awarded the housing project, then punish us at the polls in October. If you agree with our approach, then send us back in October to continue to work towards an inspiring waterfront design that will bring our community far more value than dozens of high-end waterfront homes.
Discover more from BILL GORDON - MAYOR
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I now agree with mayor and council if the RFP did not come close. The idea is just on pause!
I agree with your pause on this site Mayor thankyou for listening to Midlanders. We need a place to be for Midland people to enjoy and not be overlooked by homes or apartments . So Thankyou for that . We have a lot of homes surrounding our Georgian bay as it is ! My opinion !
I agree with this council’s position to pause the development process of MBL. It reinforces the fact that when the public speaks loud enough, our elected officials are more likely to listen. Thanks for listening.
I further support, as eluded by Mayor Gordon, that we explore taking over the planning and development of this site within the town. Taking the responsibility within our governing structure and recruiting the right talent to do so would likely result in an outcome better aligned with the wishes of our community. It would be a big task but putting staff and our elected officials’ neck in the noose would more likely ensure that they act responsibly.
I have not always seen eye-to-eye with this mayor in regards to protecting public access to Georgian Bay waters (numerous attempts to sell Lakewood Drive waterfront trail) but on this one we agree.
The next council will have to make the right moves. No more pauses, no more money thrown at consultants…